
MALAPPURAM: The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Malappuram, has directed Samsung India Electronics Pvt Ltd to pay Rs 20,000 to a consumer after an air conditioner purchased from the company became unusable because a defective circuit board could not be replaced due to the non-availability of the spare part.The commission also directed Samsung’s authorised service centre, KC Cooling Technology, to refund Rs 500 collected from the consumer as a visiting charge despite no repair being carried out. Samsung and the service centre have jointly been ordered to pay Rs 10,000 as compensation for deficiency in service and Rs 5,000 towards litigation expenses.The order was passed on October 30, 2026, on a complaint filed by Sakeer V P of Malappuram.According to the complaint, Sakeer purchased a Samsung AR12NV3JGMCNNA air conditioner from Shajahan T V & Fridge House-2016 in Perinthalmanna on August 6, 2018, for Rs 39,000. He said the purchase was made on the assurance of product quality and durability, with the company offering a 12-month comprehensive warranty and additional warranty coverage.After more than six years of use, the AC developed a cooling problem. On May 14, 2025, the authorised service centre inspected the unit and found a defect in its printed circuit board (PCB). Technicians advised replacement of the defective component.However, the service centre demanded Rs 2,500 towards repair charges, which the consumer paid. Subsequently, he was informed that the required PCB was unavailable with Samsung and the AC could not be repaired. The service centre refunded Rs 2,000 but retained Rs 500 as visiting charges.The consumer approached the commission, alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practice. He sought a refund of Rs 39,000 with interest and Rs 25,000 as compensation for mental agony and inconvenience.Samsung, in its defence, admitted the purchase and the 10-year warranty coverage but said the defect had occurred after more than six years of usage. It maintained that the PCB was unavailable and that it had offered a depreciated refund, which the consumer rejected. The company argued that repairs outside the applicable warranty period were chargeable.The commission observed that although the parties had referred to a 10-year warranty, the warranty document showed 12 months of comprehensive coverage and an additional 48 months of warranty for the condenser. It said the dispute was not about the duration of the warranty but the manufacturer’s responsibility to ensure the availability of spare parts.The commission held that a consumer’s right to repair a product could not be shut down merely because the manufacturer failed to make spare parts available. It found that Samsung had failed to provide the required PCB and had thereby committed deficiency in service.It also held the authorised service centre liable for collecting Rs 500 despite not carrying out the repair. The commission said Samsung, as manufacturer, and the service centre were jointly and severally liable for the deficiency.However, it found no evidence of deficiency in service or unfair trade practice against the retailer and exonerated it from liability.Considering that the AC had been used for more than six years and the consumer had purchased another unit for Rs 33,000, the commission directed Samsung to pay Rs 20,000 after accounting for depreciation.Samsung was also directed to take back the defective AC within 45 days, bearing packaging and transportation costs if required. It can collect the unit only after making the entire payment ordered by the commission. If it fails to do so within the stipulated period, the consumer will not be required to retain or return the defective product.The commission directed Samsung and the service centre to comply with the order within 45 days, failing which the entire amount will attract 9% annual interest from the date of the order until realisation.